Your annual health-insurance bill might feel like a ball and chain on your wallet—but what if you could legally slash it with little-known tax breaks? In both the United States and Canada, smart taxpayers are quietly leveraging provisions that dramatically reduce net premiums or even erase them entirely. In this deep-dive, you’ll discover:
- The expanded Premium Tax Credit (PTC) in the U.S. through 2025—and how to maximize it
- Canada’s Private Health Services Plan (PHSP) deduction, a self-employed secret weapon
- Side-by-side comparison of the U.S. and Canadian approaches
- Step-by-step checklists to claim these credits and deductions
- Answers to common FAQs so you can act with confidence
Let’s unlock these loopholes and keep more of your hard-earned money in your pocket.
What Is the Premium Tax Credit—and What Changed for 2025?
The Premium Tax Credit (PTC) is a refundable tax credit that helps eligible individuals and families cover premiums for health plans purchased through the federal or state marketplaces under the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Traditionally, the PTC phased out at 400% of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL).
Loophole: Through the end of the 2025 coverage year, Congress eliminated the upper‐income cap, so taxpayers with household income over 400% of FPL may still qualify—if their benchmark plan exceeds 8.5% of their income. This extension is set to expire after 2025 unless Congress acts again.
- Expanded eligibility (2021–2025): No maximum‐income limit for the PTC
- Cost cap of 8.5% of income: If your benchmark plan (the second‐lowest-cost Silver plan) costs more than 8.5% of your household income, you qualify
- Refundable credit: Even if you owe no tax, you can receive the excess as a refund
You’ll find the IRS’s official Q&A on these temporary enhancements here: Questions and Answers on the Premium Tax Credit.
How the PTC Calculation Works
- Determine your household income.
- Find 8.5% of that income.
- Compare to the benchmark plan premium.
- If premiums exceed 8.5%-of-income, you claim the difference as PTC.
- File IRS Form 8962 with your return to reconcile advance payments vs. actual credit.
Unlock the Premium Tax Credit Loophole in Five Easy Steps
Most agents will only mention the PTC’s headline provisions—but savvy taxpayers use these strategies to squeeze every cent:
- Estimate conservatively:
- Underestimate income by up to 5% to avoid under-payment penalties—this can boost your advance credit without risking an IRS “clawback.”
- Time income and deductions:
- Delay bonuses until January or accelerate deductible expenses (like HSA contributions) into December to lower your 2025 MAGI.
- Max out pretax accounts:
- HSAs, FSAs, SIMPLE IRAs, and 401(k)s reduce Adjusted Gross Income (AGI), increasing your PTC.
- Reconcile with precision:
- Gather your Form 1095-A (Marketplace statement) and file Form 8962 early.
- Monitor legislative updates:
- If Congress extends the expanded PTC beyond 2025, adjust planning accordingly.
Pro Tip: Even if you’re above 400% of FPL, you might still pay zero net premium—just ensure your benchmark Silver plan’s premium is above 8.5% of your AGI.
Health Insurance Tax Credit Loophole in Canada: The Self-Employed PHSP Deduction
Canadians don’t have a U.S.-style refundable credit for private health insurance, but self-employed and incorporated individuals can tap the Private Health Services Plan (PHSP). Under CRA rules, 100% of eligible medical and dental expenses paid through a PHSP are deductible as a business expense—effectively giving you a dollar-for-dollar tax break.
Learn more about which premiums qualify and how to set up a PHSP at Ratehub’s guide: Is Health Insurance Tax Deductible in Canada?
Key Benefits of a PHSP
- 100% Deductible: Premiums and reimbursements processed through the PHSP are fully deductible from business income.
- No dollar limit: Unlike the regular Medical Expense Tax Credit (which is limited to expenses above 3% of your net income or a fixed threshold), PHSPs have no such floor.
- Covers dependents: You can reimburse expenses for yourself, your spouse, children, and even other dependents.
- Sets up in minutes: Many insurers offer turnkey PHSP administration.
U.S. vs. Canada: Side-by-Side Comparison
Feature | U.S. Premium Tax Credit (PTC) | Canada PHSP Deduction |
---|---|---|
Who qualifies? | Individuals/families buying ACA Marketplace plans | Self-employed sole proprietors, partnerships, corporations |
Type of benefit | Refundable tax credit | Deduction against business income |
Income limit | No cap through 2025 (benchmark plan >8.5% of income) | No cap |
Clawback risk | Yes—if advance payments exceed actual credit, must repay | No |
Timing mods | Adjust income timing, maximize pretax contributions | Plan reimbursements anytime PHSP exists |
Administrative complexity | Moderate (estimates, Form 8962, 1095-A) | Low (insurer/third-party admin handles claims) |
Net premium cost | Potentially zero for many households | Zero net cost if business profits support premiums |
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can I still get the PTC if my income is $200,000?
Yes—but only through 2025. If your benchmark plan costs more than 8.5% of your household income, you qualify regardless of how high your income is.
2. What happens after 2025?
Unless Congress extends the expanded eligibility, the old 400% FPL cap returns for 2026.
3. Do I need to reconcile advance PTC payments?
Always. File Form 8962 with your tax return to compare what you received vs. what you qualify for. Overpayments must be repaid; underpayments yield an additional credit.
4. Is a PHSP right for my small Canadian business?
If you have consistent profits and want to provide comprehensive health and dental coverage while reducing taxable income, a PHSP is ideal.
5. Can I combine these strategies?
Only one applies based on your residency and business status—U.S. PTC for Marketplace enrollees, Canadian PHSP for self-employed individuals.
Conclusion: Act Now—Loopholes Disappear
These tax-credit strategies are temporary and complex enough that most agents won’t even mention them:
- U.S. taxpayers have until December 31, 2025, to exploit the income-cap removal on the Premium Tax Credit.
- Self-employed Canadians can set up a PHSP immediately to deduct 100% of health and dental expenses.
Plan proactively:
- Review your income projections and adjust timing.
- Max out HSAs/FSAs in the U.S.; establish a PHSP in Canada.
- File the right forms—8843/Form 8962 in the U.S., schedule your PHSP reimbursements in Canada.
By unlocking these loopholes now, you could pay zero net premiums—but only if you act before these provisions sunset. Don’t let your agent miss this opportunity: take control of your health-insurance costs today.