Why Health Insurance Claims Get Denied

Understanding the denial rationale empowers you to build a stronger appeal. Insurance companies use automated systems and medical reviewers to process thousands of claims. They may deny your claim for administrative errors, coverage exclusions, or medical necessity disputes.

• Administrative Errors
  • Incorrect policy numbers
  • Missing or mismatched patient identifiers
  • Coding mistakes (CPT, ICD-10)
• Coverage Exclusions
  • Non-covered services (cosmetic procedures, elective treatments)
  • Out-of-network providers
  • Waiting periods for pre-existing conditions
• Medical Necessity
  • Insurer deems procedure “experimental”
  • Alternative treatments covered first
  • Insufficient documentation

When you receive a denial letter, review the Explanation of Benefits (EOB). It lists the denial code and a brief reason. Refer to your policy’s Summary of Benefits for covered services and prior authorization requirements.

Pro Tip: Keep a denial tracker—log date of denial, denial code, and appeal deadline.

---

 

How to Appeal Health Insurance Denial

Appealing promptly and thoroughly increases your chances of overturning a denial. Follow these actionable steps:

1. Review Your Denial Notice
   • Identify the denial code and reason.
   • Check appeal deadlines (often 60–180 days).
2. Gather Your Policy Documents
   • Review exclusions, prior authorization rules, and coverage limits.
   • Highlight relevant sections.
3. Collect Supporting Evidence
   • Medical records, test results, physician letters.
   • Peer-reviewed research supporting the treatment’s efficacy.
4. Draft Your Appeal Letter
   • Use a clear, concise format.
   • Reference policy provisions and attach evidence.
5. Submit Your Appeal
   • Follow insurer’s appeal process (online portal, fax, mail).
   • Obtain proof of submission (tracking number, fax confirmation).
6. Follow Up
   • If you don’t hear back within 30 days, call to confirm receipt.
   • Request status updates every 2–3 weeks.
7. Escalate if Necessary
   • File an external review through your state’s Department of Insurance.
   • Engage a patient advocate or attorney if denied again.

---

 

Common Reasons for Claim Denials

Identifying the root cause of denial helps you tailor your appeal. Below is a quick-reference table summarizing frequent denial reasons and how to address them:

Denial Reason	Description	How to Address
Administrative Error	Data entry or coding mistakes	Correct codes; verify patient info
Lack of Authorization	Missing prior authorization	Obtain and attach authorization letter
Non-Covered Service	Service excluded in policy	Cite medical necessity; request exception
Out-of-Network Provider	Provider not in insurer’s network	Show “medical emergency” clause
Experimental Treatment	Service labeled “investigational”	Provide peer-reviewed clinical studies
Duplicate Billing	Claim already processed	Confirm duplicate; rectify submission
Maximum Benefit Exceeded	Annual or lifetime limit reached	Appeal for financial hardship exception

Keep this table handy as you prepare each appeal.

---

 

Collecting Supporting Documentation

You strengthen your appeal by providing robust evidence. Here’s what to include:

• Medical Records & Test Results
  • Imaging (MRI, CT scans)
  • Lab reports with normal/abnormal indicators
• Physician Letters
  • A detailed letter of medical necessity from your treating doctor.
  • Include credentials, specialty, and treatment rationale.
• Peer‑Reviewed Research
  • Cite reputable journals (e.g., Journal of the American Medical Association).
  • Link to studies showing positive outcomes (JAMA).
• Prior Authorization Documents
  • Approval codes and dates.
  • Correspondence logs with insurer representatives.
• Billing Statements
  • Itemized billing showing charges and payments.
  • EOB from previous related claims.

Quick Checklist:

• Medical necessity letter
• Test results and imaging
• Peer-reviewed studies
• Prior authorization evidence
• Itemized billing & EOBs

Organize documents in a binder or a PDF portfolio. Label each section by document type to streamline the reviewer’s task.

---

 

Writing an Insurance Appeal Letter Template

Your letter serves as the narrative backbone of your appeal. Keep it structured, factual, and persuasive:

[Your Name]
[Your Address]
[City, State ZIP]
[Policy Number] | [Claim Number]
[Date]

To:
Appeals Department
[Insurance Company Name]
[Insurer Address]

Subject: Appeal of Denied Claim – [Date of Service]

---

1. Introduction & Purpose

“I, [Your Name], respectfully appeal the denial of coverage for [Service/Procedure] provided on [Date]. I believe this service meets the criteria for coverage under my policy, and I request a full review of my claim.”

2. Policy Reference

• Policy Section: cite the exact section that covers your procedure (e.g., “Section 3.2, p. 12, covers medically necessary imaging”).
• Plan Type: HMO/PPO/EPO—confirm network status.

3. Medical Necessity Argument

• Clinical Diagnosis: ICD‑10 Code(s) with description.
• Physician’s Opinion: “Dr. Smith, MD, Board‑Certified in Neurology, states the procedure is essential…”
• Supporting Evidence: list attached test results, medical literature, and FDA approvals.

4. Counter Arguments to Denial

Insurer’s Reason	Your Rebuttal
“Service deemed experimental”	Provide 3 peer‑reviewed studies confirming standard use.
“Prior authorization missing”	Include authorization letter dated [Date].

5. Conclusion & Request

“Based on the evidence provided, I respectfully request that you overturn the denial and approve coverage for the referenced claim in full.”

Attachments:

1. Medical necessity letter
2. Test results & imaging
3. Peer-reviewed studies
4. Prior authorization letter

Sincerely,
[Your Signature]
[Typed Name]

Use this template to ensure you hit every critical point.

---

 

Submitting the Appeal to Your Insurer

Follow these steps to ensure your appeal reaches the right hands:

1. Check Submission Channels
   • Online Portal: Many insurers allow digital upload.
   • Fax: Send to the appeals fax number. Retain the confirmation.
   • Certified Mail: Use “return receipt requested” to track delivery.
2. Document Proof of Submission
   • Screenshot the portal confirmation.
   • Save the fax receipt or USPS tracking info.
3. Record Contact Log
   • Date, time, representative name, summary of conversation.
4. Monitor Deadlines
   • Set calendar reminders 30, 60, and 90 days post‑submission.
5. Be Proactive
   • If you haven’t received an acknowledgment within 14 days, call to confirm receipt.

Submitting correctly avoids delays that could force you to restart the appeal clock.

---

 

Appeal Health Insurance Claim Deadlines

Missing deadlines often leads to automatic forfeiture of your appeal rights. Here’s a quick breakdown:

Stage	Deadline from Date of Denial
Internal Appeal – Level 1	60 days (ERISA plans)
Internal Appeal – Level 2	Additional 60 days
State External Review	4–6 months (varies by state)
Medicare Redetermination	120 days
Medicare Reconsideration	180 days

Note: Unlike ERISA plans, state‑regulated policies may offer longer appeal windows. Check your state’s Department of Insurance website (e.g., NAIC State Map).

Add these dates to your calendar immediately upon denial.

---

 

Escalating Your Appeal: External Review

If your insurer upholds the denial after all internal levels, you can seek an independent external review.

1. Eligibility Check
   • Applies when you’ve exhausted internal appeals.
   • State or federal guidelines (for ERISA plans, see DOL External Review).
2. Filing for External Review
   • Submit request to your state’s Department of Insurance or to the federal external review body (for self-funded plans).
   • Include: internal denial letters, appeal outcome, and supporting documents.
3. Independent Reviewer Assignment
   • The agency assigns a neutral third‑party medical reviewer.
   • Reviewer examines your clinical evidence, insurer’s denial rationale, and applicable medical standards.
4. Decision Timeline
   • Many states require decision within 45 days of receipt.
   • Expedited reviews available for urgent or emergency services.
5. Outcome
   • Binding on the insurer.
   • If favorable, insurer must pay claim and applicable interest or penalties.

External review offers a final, impartial opportunity to secure coverage.

---

 

Tips to Avoid Future Claim Denials

Learning from past denials can streamline your next submission:

• Verify Coverage Before Treatment
  • Call your insurer for pre‑authorization requirements.
  • Confirm network status of provider.
• Accurate Coding & Billing
  • Ensure CPT/ICD codes match clinical documentation.
  • Use professional coders when possible.
• Maintain Clear Communication
  • Document every call: date, time, rep, confirmation numbers.
  • Follow up in writing (email or fax).
• Use Patient Advocates
  • Hospital or third‑party advocates can navigate complex cases.
  • They often know insurer processes inside out.
• Keep Records Organized
  • Create digital and paper folders for each claim.
  • Name files clearly (e.g., “2025‑04‑10_MRI_Report.pdf”).

Implement these best practices to reduce stress and claim slippage.

---

 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1: How long does the appeal process take?
You typically get a written decision within 30–60 days for internal appeals. External reviews often conclude in 45 days, with expedited options for urgent cases.

Q2: Can I get legal help to appeal my claim?
Yes. Health law attorneys or consumer advocacy groups can assist—especially for complex or high‑cost claims. They often work on contingency.

Q3: What if my policy is under ERISA?
ERISA plans follow federal appeal rules: two internal levels then an external review. You can also file suit in federal court after exhausting appeals.

Q4: Is there a fee for external review?
Most states prohibit fees for patients. Confirm with your state’s insurance department.

Q5: Can I switch insurers if my appeal fails?
You may enroll in a new plan during open enrollment or after a qualifying life event. Appeals do not grant you a new policy but may restore coverage for disputed claims.

---

Take Control of Your Health Expenses
You deserve transparency and fair coverage. By following these steps—understanding denial reasons, gathering strong evidence, crafting a persuasive appeal letter, and knowing your deadlines—you can successfully challenge denied claims. Keep detailed records, stay proactive, and don’t hesitate to escalate to an external review. Your health and financial well‑being depend on it.